| Statistical computational results for simulated instances | ||||||||||||||||
| City | Task | ¡¡ | Set 3: Less to More | ¡¡ | Set 4: More to Less | ¡¡ | Set 5: More to More | |||||||||
| ¡¡ | ITC | Opt* | Delivery | Ratio | ¡¡ | ITC | Opt* | Delivery | Ratio | ¡¡ | ITC | Opt* | Delivery | Ratio | ||
| Beijing | 20 | S01 | 31590 | 72945 | 43% | S28 | 68103 | 175320 | 39% | S55 | 37849 | 199767 | 19% | |||
| 50 | S02 | 198482 | 217056 | 91% | S29 | 264989 | 438253 | 60% | S56 | 120614 | 597219 | 20% | ||||
| 80 | S03 | 355758 | 368076 | 97% | S30 | 450409 | 783666 | 57% | S57 | 242408 | 956244 | 25% | ||||
| Shanghai | 20 | S04 | 53040 | 109736 | 48% | S31 | 64445 | 112865 | 57% | S58 | 12761 | 149959 | 9% | |||
| 50 | S05 | 190792 | 285617 | 67% | S32 | 142345 | 248034 | 57% | S59 | 57177 | 372259 | 15% | ||||
| 80 | S06 | 388558 | 495813 | 78% | S33 | 292481 | 415906 | 70% | S60 | 98637 | 536804 | 18% | ||||
| Nanjing | 20 | S07 | 58564 | 96234 | 61% | S34 | 118540 | 267712 | 44% | S61 | 35248 | 197273 | 18% | |||
| 50 | S08 | 138103 | 170067 | 81% | S35 | 211106 | 455908 | 46% | S62 | 69602 | 440167 | 16% | ||||
| 80 | S09 | 350160 | 415197 | 84% | S36 | 356299 | 662222 | 54% | S63 | 177392 | 910930 | 19% | ||||
| Chengdu | 20 | S10 | 108549 | 126189 | 86% | S37 | 47300 | 98998 | 48% | S64 | 46675 | 198646 | 23% | |||
| 50 | S11 | 147830 | 222532 | 66% | S38 | 142617 | 246500 | 58% | S65 | 76187 | 408210 | 19% | ||||
| 80 | S12 | 210247 | 344046 | 61% | S39 | 258215 | 389590 | 66% | S66 | 127005 | 640866 | 20% | ||||
| Wuhan | 20 | S13 | 81090 | 95377 | 85% | S40 | 119974 | 217607 | 55% | S67 | 39832 | 203174 | 20% | |||
| 50 | S14 | 165905 | 171098 | 97% | S41 | 442668 | 671517 | 66% | S68 | 175245 | 557261 | 31% | ||||
| 80 | S15 | 255540 | 247018 | 103% | S42 | 593032 | 1016559 | 58% | S69 | 229689 | 902433 | 25% | ||||
| Xian | 20 | S16 | 146191 | 241483 | 61% | S43 | 42833 | 99076 | 43% | S70 | 44317 | 235622 | 19% | |||
| 50 | S17 | 476627 | 746675 | 64% | S44 | 132247 | 218650 | 60% | S71 | 66718 | 522216 | 13% | ||||
| 80 | S18 | 961668 | 1147381 | 84% | S45 | 222422 | 322265 | 69% | S72 | 144950 | 815840 | 18% | ||||
| Hefei | 20 | S19 | 208274 | 236995 | 88% | S46 | 47254 | 94173 | 50% | S73 | 34927 | 165133 | 21% | |||
| 50 | S20 | 378569 | 425405 | 89% | S47 | 122829 | 258396 | 48% | S74 | 113024 | 417940 | 27% | ||||
| 80 | S21 | 695401 | 735556 | 95% | S48 | 215662 | 426440 | 51% | S75 | 163010 | 648002 | 25% | ||||
| Hangzhou | 20 | S22 | 55359 | 85580 | 65% | S49 | 50321 | 156640 | 32% | S76 | 38194 | 152369 | 25% | |||
| 50 | S23 | 190333 | 210383 | 90% | S50 | 209245 | 380719 | 55% | S77 | 80087 | 359960 | 22% | ||||
| 80 | S24 | 316400 | 337980 | 94% | S51 | 498503 | 644798 | 77% | S78 | 149582 | 662997 | 23% | ||||
| Shenzhen | 20 | S25 | 90455 | 107719 | 84% | S52 | 135112 | 199443 | 68% | S79 | 27894 | 169724 | 16% | |||
| 50 | S26 | 218985 | 263846 | 83% | S53 | 318452 | 412645 | 77% | S80 | 73103 | 375575 | 19% | ||||
| ¡¡ | 80 | ¡¡ | S27 | 321331 | 344529 | 93% | ¡¡ | S54 | 493082 | 609938 | 81% | ¡¡ | S81 | 136689 | 597881 | 23% |
| Mean | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | 79% | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | 57% | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | ¡¡ | 20% |